Do the dollars we spend on vacation really count? Most of us spending money on cheap trinkets and overpriced T-shirts don't believe they do - until we get the credit-card bills.
Similarly, it appears state lawmakers believe that the money earmarked for tax-credit programs don't really count, either. That might explain the ease with which they doubled the amount of tax credits earmarked for corporate contributions to education.
The Educational Improvement Tax Credit program will grow from $75 million to $100 million, and an additional $50 million in credits will fund a new program targeted to students in the lowest-performing public schools. Under the current EITC program, corporations make contributions to organizations that provide scholarships to students or that provide educational programs to schools. Corporations then get tax credits for those contributions.
Proponents of the tax credits say they save public education dollars, because businesses are picking up the tab for students to attend private schools.
The Commonwealth Foundation even describes the EITC program as "funded through voluntary contributions from businesses."
We like the idea of corporations stepping up their responsibility to education.
But the way these credits are structured, taxpayers actually end up footing the bill for nine out of every 10 dollars spent, sometimes more, according to a recent study by the Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center.
That's because businesses can recover 75 to 90 percent of the money they donate in outright credits applied to their tax bills.
In addition, companies can also take federal and state tax deductions for charitable contributions - which means that a company can make a $300,000 contribution and end up actually spending $20 a year in out-of-pocket costs.
Given that most of these credits are designed to help students pay for private or parochial schools, it's no wonder that critics call this "voucher lite." We would have less of a problem with public money funding private or parochial schools if those schools were held accountable for performance and required to be transparent with how money is spent. But they're not.
And the tax-credit program builds in additional protections from scrutiny. The program is overseen and administered not by the Department of Education, but the state Department of Commerce and Economic Development.
A legislative committee's detailed review revealed a number of problems with oversight, including the fact that the DCED doesn't even staff its program-monitoring units. And there is no monitoring of outcomes for students who get scholarships to non-public schools.
It's like the kids get public money to go off the grid and we never get to find out if that money actually improved achievement.
Last week, the Daily News reported an even-worse scenario: Jerry Sandusky's Second Mile program received $1.4 million from the tax-credit program.
Lawmakers and proponents of EITC seem to believe that tax credits aren't real money. But tax credits directly reduce the tax revenue the state receives.
And the stakes are even higher when you consider the full range of Pennsylvania's tax credits - $344 million in 2009-2010, with little oversight or monitoring.
It's clearly time to acknowledge tax-credit programs for what they are: not "vacation money" that doesn't really count, but actual expenditures that should be managed and overseen far more seriously than they are.
Published July 21, 2012, in Allied News. Pick up a copy at 201 A Erie St., Grove City.
Opinion
Education tax credits good idea, but at what cost?
- Opinion
-
-
Seizure of AP records is insult to independent press
Distrust of government secrecy has been elevated to an exceptional level with the disclosure the Justice Department covertly examined two months of Associated Press phone records to determine who leaked details to the AP about a foiled terrorist plot.
-
Medicare: Did you really pay for that?
Last summer, Barack Obama riled a lot of entrepreneurs when he got carried away at a campaign event and told any American who had built up a successful enterprise, "you didn't build that."
-
Pa. taxes pocketbooks of working class unfairly
We often hear about how Pennsylvania's tax laws are a burden for existing businesses and a red flag for those considering setting up shop in the Keystone state.
-
Teen's shooting death could have been prevented
"There are two great days in every person's life, the day they were born - and the day they realized why."
- Rick Warren, "The Purpose-Driven Life" -
Congress should pass sweeping gun legislation
All of the aspects of President Obama's $500 million gun legislation plan could be effective in decreasing the incidence of mass shootings in the United States.
-
Let's be clear when we say 'Get guns off the streets'
Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan rightly said, "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts."
-
Lighten up: Be free to be healthier this year
So how is that New Year's resolution diet going?
-
After 2012 we can only hope for happier year
Our mothers taught us you only get one chance to make a first impression, but when it comes to the impression an old year leaves, 2012 may be remembered for its last.
-
Recalling Robert Bork's visit to GC College
On a dark February afternoon in 1988, 25 students in a U.S. Constitutional History class waited expectantly in a little-used dining hall on the campus of Grove City College (in Grove City, Pennsylvania) for a special guest lecturer to arrive.
-
The holidays can be special, and stressful
The holidays can be a special time, as well as a stressful time.
- More Opinion Headlines
-
Seizure of AP records is insult to independent press
Ex-Hit Man's Past Is a Shock to Some Neighbors
Fans: Gandofini 'Put New Jersey on the Map'
Does Future of Human Race Depend on Kansas Mine?
Reining in 'Bad News' Sports Parents
James Gandolfini Dies at Age 51
Fmr. TWA Flight 800 Investigators Want New Probe
Raw: Heat, Spurs Back on Court Ahead of Game 7
Dolce and Gabbana Convicted of Tax Evasion
Paris, Prince Depositions Used in Jackson Trial
Coiffed Cattle Get Their Close-up
In Berlin, Obama Channels Cold War Activism
Police at Patriots Tight End's Home for 2nd Day
Fed Suggests Bond Purchases Could Slow
AP: DOJ Broke Own Rules Seizing Phone Records
Raw: Baby White Rhino Debuts at Australian Zoo
Time Lapse: Rebuilding Bridge Post-collapse
Ohio Woman Accuses 3 of Holding Her Captive
Hunt for Ex-Teamster Boss Hoffa's Remains Ends
